Una ancianita americana (85) que participó en la Revolución Cultural haciendo un AMA. La cosa se lía cuando empiezan a aparecer los descendientes de la víctimas
http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/4 ... n_who_was/
I was assigned to teach English in a college level institute in Beijing that I was chauffeured to and from while residing in the elegant “Friendship Hotel.” I objected to these special elegant conditions and wanted to be on the same salary and living conditions as my co-teachers. This brought me into participation in writing a “Big Character” poster (dao zi bao) which led to full permission for me to take part both in my institute and among all the foreigners who chose to participate in the Cultural Revolution.
In 1969 the 9th Congress of the Chinese Communist Party called for the correction of several mistakes made during the Cultural Revolution such as ending factionalism, setting up a new constitution for China and keeping criticism of leadership at the highest levels possible including the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party. At this point I had put 5 years of hard work into supporting the movement and with these important steps taken chose to return home to the US to support my ailing mother and felt it was important to support and participate in the movement in the US to oppose the war in Viet Nam.
http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/4 ... as/d0y1nlj
Hey, thank you for doing this AMA.
However, I have some questions for you, I am ethnically Chinese. My paternal grandfather fought and bled in the Chinese revolution for Mao. He was in the Chinese Communist Army and Party from 1940 onwards and fought in some of the bloodiest battles during the wars and rose to the rank equivalent of Colonel. He told me when he was still alive that he had 4 of his friends die in his arms when he fought against the Japanese and the KMT. He had a picture taken with Mao himself which my family still has.
During the cultural revolution he was purged from the People's liberation army for refusing to denounce his superior (the Marshal He Long who was another revolutionary hero who was unjustly accused of being a counter-revolutionary), and tossed into a labor camp. He was subjected to physical and mental torture for years before being released. My grandfather's home was raided by red guards, my grandmother had to flee with my father, uncle and aunt into the countryside to escape further persecution. To this day those memories still pain her.
My maternal grandfather and grandmother were both college professors who were forced into "airplane positions" (
http://www.harunyahya.com/image/communi ... k05.16.jpg) for hours. They were publicly humiliated by their students, paraded in dunce caps, subjected to struggle sessions which drove many of their colleagues to suicides, and worried daily that red guards were going to come into their home and steal everything from them.
Both of my parents were sent down youth who were forced into the countryside because Mao decided to toss away the young people who supported him when they outlived their usefulness, even if they did not participate in the cultural revolution at all.
In this context can you answer me the following:
1) Do you consider my grandfather a "revisionist"?
2) Did my intellectual grandparents deserved to be in "struggle sessions"?
3) In the light of the brutality and cruelty the cultural revolution inflicted even on the men who fought to found the People's Republic, how can you consider this to be a positive for China?
4) Do you feel the physical and emotional cost of a generation of youth, often middle and high schoolers, being used as political tools against domestic political opponents was justified?
5) Do you think the Chinese people's collective negative view of the cultural revolution today is correct?
Thank you if you happen to read this.
Edit: I've being getting messages about today's politics so I just want to clarify. My post is meant to raise a matter of Chinese history and my family's connection to it. I know that emotions are running high in the current American electoral cycle but I don't consider my post to be very relevant because the situation in China in 1966 and America in 2016 are simply not comparable.
For those of you interested, I strongly recommend Mao's Last Revolution by Michael Schoenhals and Roderick MacFarquhar for further readings.